October 2005

Good Morning!

My friend Brad Howe stuck a chord with the subject of his newsletter earlier this month… personal guarantees of business obligations. I not only read it with interest, I decided to take it one step further (yes, indeed, we business authors can be inspired by other writers!)

I look forward to hearing your thoughts and experiences on the subject when we share a cup of coffee tomorrow morning and welcome former Lieutenant Governor Tom O'Neill to SBANE's Massachusetts Breakfast Series. Seems like every entrepreneur has at least one horror story about a personal guarantee so, feel free to share it (we always change names to protect the innocent and not so innocent).


Cordially,

Marijo


Marijo McCarthy, Esq.
President, Widett and McCarthy, P.C.

What Does A Personal Guarantee Really Mean?
 

Did you know that…

…if you own 20% or more of a business (a corporation or limited liability company) and your business borrows money from a bank, you will most likely be asked to personally guarantee it?

…if your business fails to pay its obligations, the bank could decide to pursue you personally, rather than being required to assemble and sell your business assets first, or even at all?

…even though you own only 20% of the company, the bank could decide to collect 100% of the obligation from you, particularly if you have a nice, liquid savings account?

Sobering thoughts? You bet they are!

That said, since personal guarantees are a way of life in the small business world, there are ways of managing the risk of losing, through no fault of your own other than being part of an uncertain economy, all of your savings… maybe even your home.

First, let's understand why a personal guarantee is requested so much (most) of the time and why you should not be surprised or insulted when asked for one.

Sometimes a bank is seeking to fill a perceived credit gap, i.e., your business assets consist of office equipment and not much else and you want to borrow $500,000.00 for growth expansion. Sometimes it is a "character" loan — almost no business assets but your good character, and you want to borrow $50,000.00 based upon that.

Second, are you aware that you can sometimes negotiate the terms of a personal guarantee?

For instance, depending upon the strength of your business credit, you can:

  1. try and negotiate it away. In my experience, go for the gold and settle for the silver (if you start with silver, you might not even end up with bronze!).
  2. try and narrow the scope of the guarantee. Ask the lender to release it after one full year of timely payments, or when the obligation is reduced to a certain amount, or to limit it to a certain percentage of the obligation.
  3. try and get the guarantee divided into percentages based on ownership. This way, if you do in fact own just 20%, your obligation is for just 20% of the guarantee.

Third, if you find yourself stuck with a personal guarantee, think long and hard about how this may affect you and your fellow business owners down the road.

For instance, if both you and your partner agree to sign a personal guarantee (something you want to discuss with each other before you are sitting in the bank, signing loan documents!), make sure to consider the possible inequities of your individual financial situations.

One of you may be single and thrifty — a home with a lot of equity, a solid stock portfolio and a hefty savings account, while the other may have a spouse, several kids, a huge mortgage and no liquid assets. Under these circumstances, who do you think the bank would choose to pursue, in the event of a business default? At that point, it's too late to wonder how to recoup your 100% loss from your 50% partner!

My advice? Discuss it in advance and document your agreement well before the cataclysmic event occurs. The fewer unpleasant surprises partners have to face, the more they have the resources… financial, mental, emotional… to face the everyday challenges that arise. And that, after all, is the ultimate challenge.

Entering into a personal guarantee is just one of the many contracts into which you, as a business owner, will enter during the course of operating a company. But it generally is the one with the most potential for personal, financial impact. Many business owners casually sign away on personal guarantees without clearly understanding the breadth and scope of this particular agreement. Don't you be one of them!

Things We Like
 

December 26, 2004 — Tsunami struck South Asia and East Africa… and The Red Cross was there.

August 3, 2005 — Famine struck Niger in Africa… and The Red Cross was there.

August 29, 2005 — Massive hurricane struck Gulf Coast of the United States… and The Red Cross was there.

October 8, 2005 — Earthquake struck Pakistan… and The Red Cross was there.

October 10, 2005 — Torrential rains and floods struck New Hampshire … and The Red Cross was there.

Last month, all we could think to do was stand in awe of the need and give when we could. But the tragedies nature has wrought on our neighbors here and around the world, just in the past year alone, are unrelenting and the resources have been stretched to the limit. We write a check and then go back to our lives… giving a thought to others when we turn on the evening news.

But this month, we're done talking at Widett and McCarthy… we have come up with a simple plan to give something back on a regular basis now and through the end of the year. In recognition of the need and in honor of our clients in whose success we share and applaud, we pledge to give 10% of every single client bill on which we receive payment during the last quarter of 2005.

Since we understand that "imitation is the sincerest form of flattery," we hope our readers will flatter us by copying our plan and give to The Red Cross at www.redcross.org, at whatever level they can, until the end of 2005. The Red Cross is there when so many need them and the need is so great… we will recognize that incredible commitment with a small gesture of our own… to help our global neighbors… in honor of our clients.

About Us
 

Widett and McCarthy helps small business owners start, grow, acquire and sell their businesses.

We serve as "in-house counsel" . . . on-call when needed, but not part of the company overhead. Our best clients understand that the relationship between lawyer and client is a two-way street, built on information sharing and problem solving.

For more information regarding
how we can help you, click here.

Enter your email address below to subscribe










Widett and McCarthy, P.C.
1075 Washington Street
West Newton, MA 02465

Telephone: 617.964.5559
Facsimile: 617.964.5529

Email Us | Visit Our Website


Useful Links. . .
The information you obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice.
You should consult an attorney for individual advice regarding your own situation.

Widett and McCarthy · 1075 Washington Street · West Newton · MA · 02465

Copyright � 2005 Widett & McCarthy.

Newsletter Developed by Blue Penguin Development